The Infatuation's Restaurant Picks

The Infatuation is an app and website, which uses a small team of local editors who dine anonymously to rate and review restaurants. Each restaurant gets a rating, so that you can find the right place for every occasion.

Best American Restaurants in Long Island

View all

Best American Restaurants in Long Island

Best Italian Restaurants in Long Island

View all

Best Italian Restaurants in Long Island

Popular restaurants in New York Area

Browse some of the most booked restaurants in New York Area

HAVEN Riverfront Restaurant and Bar
(288)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Edgewater
Smoke Jazz and Supper Club
(282)
$$$$
Contemporary American | Upper West Side
Shaking Crab - Upper West Side
(122)
$$$$
Cajun | Upper West Side
View all New York Area restaurants

10 Hard-to-Get Reservations in New York City

We know a thing or two about snagging a table. See the spots that are hardest to get into.
View all

10 Hard-to-Get Reservations in New York City

Local Favorites: The 20 Best Restaurants in New York City

The top restaurants in the city, according to our savvy dining experts.
View all

Local Favorites: The 20 Best Restaurants in New York City

The Top 15 Restaurants by Cuisine in New York City

Whether it’s a margherita pizza or sashimi you seek, here are the best places by cuisine type, according to our tastemakers.
View all

The Top 15 Restaurants by Cuisine in New York City

New York City’s 10 Most Iconic Restaurants

Fall in love with these longstanding local favorites.
View all

New York City’s 10 Most Iconic Restaurants

Treat your taste buds: Explore Long Island restaurants.

Earn Free Meals Faster with Bonus Points

Long Island / Hamptons's most booked Bonus Point tables
Ara Greek Kitchen & BarAra Greek Kitchen & Bar
121 reviews
$$$$
Greek | Commack, Long Island / Hamptons

My family and I love this place. The food is fantastic. The selection is large, there is something for everyone. The service is very friendly and attentive. More

OpenTable Diner -
Insignia Prime Steak & SushiInsignia Prime Steak & Sushi
3024 reviews
$$$$
Steakhouse | Smithtown, Long Island / Hamptons

Amazing . Staff was awesome. Food was delicious. I had one of the Australian steaks. The best steak ever!! More

OpenTable Diner -
Red Salt Room by David BurkeRed Salt Room by David Burke
223 reviews
$$$$
American | Garden City, Long Island / Hamptons

Everything was absolutely great! Delicious food, wonderful ambience and outstanding service.. You must go! More

OpenTable Diner -
Jewel by Tom SchaudelJewel by Tom Schaudel
1659 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Melville, Long Island / Hamptons

The poached lobster is delicious. The dessert martinis are amazing. I would like to see some new drink options, but there happy hour is fun. I do think they can improve their dinner drink service. There have been times when I had to go up to the bar to order drinks because our waiter didn’t come around enough to ask us if we were ready for another. Maybe they need someone to be in charge of just that? More

OpenTable Diner -
RARE650RARE650
2826 reviews
$$$$
Steak | Syosset, Long Island / Hamptons

The food was delicious and the attentive staff even better. More

OpenTable Diner -

Specials at top restaurants in Long Island / Hamptons

Enjoy great restaurant specials, set menus, and more
Oniro TavernaOniro Taverna
230 reviews
$$$$
Mediterranean | Woodbury, Long Island / Hamptons

food was excellent--presentation was excellent and so was service. I would definitely recommend this restaurant More

OpenTable Diner -
IMC Restaurant & BarIMC Restaurant & Bar
658 reviews
$$$$
Steakhouse | Huntington, Long Island / Hamptons

See all specials

Great service. Excellent food. Beautiful ambiance. Great staff. More

OpenTable Diner -
George Martin's Strip SteakGeorge Martin's Strip Steak
1959 reviews
$$$$
Steakhouse | East Islip, Long Island / Hamptons

Always a great dining experience here! Attentive servers and excellent food. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sangria 71 of CommackSangria 71 of Commack
40 reviews
$$$$
Spanish | Commack, Long Island / Hamptons

This is a true Spanish restaurant not a Mexican restaurant. It has a varied menu which should please many. Prices are reasonable and service was very good. Very busy on the weekends. More

OpenTable Diner -
Vilai Divine Greek CuisineVilai Divine Greek Cuisine
66 reviews
$$$$
Mediterranean | Glen Cove, Long Island / Hamptons

See all specials

Excellent Greek restaurant which Glen Cove had been missing. Went for the price fixe menu but will return. More

OpenTable Diner -

Diners' Choice Winners: Best Overall

Long Island / Hamptons's best restaurants based upon thousands of OpenTable diner reviews
La Ginestra - NY1. La Ginestra - NY
203 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Glen Cove, Long Island / Hamptons

Valentines Day. Waiters did very well to keep up with the crowd. Love this place! Owner very attentive! More

OpenTable Diner -
Chachama Grill2. Chachama Grill
1079 reviews
$$$$
Contemporary American | Patchogue, Long Island / Hamptons

First time at Chachama and we will definitely be going back. My husband and i were celebrating our 30th wedding anniversary and once the staff got wind of it they went all out to make it extra special with champagne, candles in our dessert ,music and singing!!! It was so unexpected and really made our night so special!!!! Food and service were all outstanding!! Cant wait to go back on a Thursday to try the latim menu 😀 More

OpenTable Diner -
Doma Land + Sea3. Doma Land + Sea
17 reviews
$$$$
American | Cedarhurst, Long Island / Hamptons

A most excellent dining experience! Everything was perfect; from my cocktail to the appetizer combo of foie gras and duck prosciutto to the branzino with lemon and capers. Waiters are attentive, food arrives promptly, and is divine. And those doughnuts! Warm and flavorful witha touch of sugar. A perfect ending to an exquisite meal. More

OpenTable Diner -
King Umberto Restaurant4. King Umberto Restaurant
772 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Elmont, Long Island / Hamptons

Food was average. For average, it was a bit expensive. But the service was EXCELLENT. Our waiter was really awesome and attentive. More

OpenTable Diner -
Sant Ambroeus - Southampton5. Sant Ambroeus - Southampton
97 reviews
$$$$
Italian | Southampton, Long Island / Hamptons

Consistently delicious. Best restaurant in the hamptons ! More

OpenTable Diner -

New to OpenTable

Long Island / Hamptons restaurants that recently joined the OpenTable network
Blue GooseBlue Goose
$$$$
American | Patchogue, Long Island / Hamptons

Freshly crafted food made to make your stomach smile!More

Cafe Red of Kings ParkCafe Red of Kings Park
$$$$
Contemporary American | Kings Park, Long Island / Hamptons

Warm, woodsy spot with a full bar for Italian fare & creative takes on American eats.More

Gino's of CommackGino's of Commack
$$$$
Italian | Commack, Long Island / Hamptons

Welcome to Gino's of Commack!
Inspired by everyday family cooking that we grew up with, you’ll feel at home while savoring a great meal in our casual and relaxed dining room. Experience our inventive cuisine, attentive service, and a friendly atmosphere; come see what makes us one of the most popular restaurants in town.More

Maui Chop HouseMaui Chop House
$$$$
Hawaiian | Rocky Point, Long Island / Hamptons

In 1905, my great grandparents came to Hawaii from Portugal. They landed in Maui to work the sugar cane plantations. For 3 generations my family lived on Maui and Molokai. My oldest brother was born there before my parents moved to Long Island and the rest is history. With great help and support from so many people….George, Kevin and I are proud to give you Maui Chop House! We hope you can kick back and relax while the island vibe takes you over! Hawaiian shirts and flip flops welcome! Mahalo for the Aloha! More

Mr. P's Southern SkilletMr. P's Southern Skillet
$$$$
Southern | Port Jefferson, Long Island / Hamptons

After owning L.I Pour House Bar and Grill for four years, Anthony Pallino met Executive chef Anthony Citarella and knew that not only Port Jeff but the whole Island has been missing something special. Creating Mr.P's Southern Skillet together it features Live Music alongside 5 star cooking in a relaxing atmosphere.More